Personally I do not really like peer reviews. In the past when I am doing a review I will take my time going over the paper and try to give some real positive feedback on how to help someone with their papers. I have always found the responses back to me have been short, and normally like I love your paper great job I like .... best. I really do not want responses like that. I want a response to tell me something I can improve on. Not necessarily something I have done wrong but there are always spots that people can improve on and that is what I am more so looking for. I think each person is different and I may get a review from someone that will be helpful. But up to this point I have not really gotten any real feedback from peer reviews that I have found helpful in revising my papers.
Amanda Sirk
I like how you just put it out there good job!!! I love it and see no room for improvment!! LOL
ReplyDeleteThank you Jenny, its just how I feel. I put a lot of work into what I tell people and take the time and I just like the same in return I guess!
ReplyDeleteAmanda